Hi everyone:
This is just to remind you that we will have two make up sections:
10 am Section:
Friday 12pm, Emerson 101
Monday 10am, your regular room
11am section:
Friday 12pm, Emerson 101
Monday 11am, your regular room
Remember that on Monday you also have a lecture in Sanders
Tuesday, November 13, 2007
Friday, November 9, 2007
A good example of price discrimination
I am currently looking for tickets to travel to Chile for end of year holidays. Even though it is not a monopoly (but it is close), LAN (chilean airline) is the airline I try to use. Well, If you go to any travel agency or if you look at the 'super special offers' if I travel before Dec 16th, the cost of the ticket via NY is $1000. If I travel starting the 16th it costs .... $1900 !!!!
Do you think the costs for LAN change dramatically before and after Dec 16th? Of course not! This is price discrimination. They know that the people that travel close to Christmas value A LOT getting to their homes close to the 24th of December and they charge you for that. People that travel before the 16th on average are traveling for other reasons so they are less willing to accept a price so much higher.
I wouldn't care traveling before the 16th, but I have one final exam on the 19th, so I am screwed.
Is this legal? Yes it is, because they are not discriminating specific people, they are just changing the price depending the time of the year, so everyone that wants to travel on that date (and buys as late as I do) has to pay that price. But they are effectively extracting a LOT of consumer surplus from the people that need and want to travel close to Xmas to Chile.
Do you think the costs for LAN change dramatically before and after Dec 16th? Of course not! This is price discrimination. They know that the people that travel close to Christmas value A LOT getting to their homes close to the 24th of December and they charge you for that. People that travel before the 16th on average are traveling for other reasons so they are less willing to accept a price so much higher.
I wouldn't care traveling before the 16th, but I have one final exam on the 19th, so I am screwed.
Is this legal? Yes it is, because they are not discriminating specific people, they are just changing the price depending the time of the year, so everyone that wants to travel on that date (and buys as late as I do) has to pay that price. But they are effectively extracting a LOT of consumer surplus from the people that need and want to travel close to Xmas to Chile.
Answers to questions in section
Hi:
Here are the answers to other questions asked in class
- If all firms are equal, in a situation of losses where firms in the long run exit, how do we know which ones exit and which ones not? Do all exit at the same time?
This is a very good question and I have found it difficult to provide a convincing answer. But talking to other TFs and doing some research has indicated me that, as I explained in class, one possible explanation to why it is not the case that all firms exit at the same time despite having the same cost structure, is that firms can enter the long run in different periods of time. Some firms renew contracts and fixed costs in some months and others in others. So the 'entrance' into the long run can differ by firm. So in a situation of losses not ALL of them exit at the same time, but only a group of them do.
- If we sum all the marginal costs and obtain market supply, is the producer surplus equal to the profits of all firms?
No, producer surplus considers only the variable part of profits of all firms. To obtain the profits from producer surplus we must subtract the fixed costs of each firm from producer surplur. Or, in other words profits are lower than producer surplus because they consider fixed costs in their calculation, while producer surplus does not.
- (technical question) Is the slope of the average cost curve the difference of the average cost and the marginal cost at each quantity?
Not exactly, but close. The answer requires calculus and derivatives. Could the person that asked me this question send me an email so I can give you an exact answer? I don't want to post it publicly because its just math derivations.
Here are the answers to other questions asked in class
- If all firms are equal, in a situation of losses where firms in the long run exit, how do we know which ones exit and which ones not? Do all exit at the same time?
This is a very good question and I have found it difficult to provide a convincing answer. But talking to other TFs and doing some research has indicated me that, as I explained in class, one possible explanation to why it is not the case that all firms exit at the same time despite having the same cost structure, is that firms can enter the long run in different periods of time. Some firms renew contracts and fixed costs in some months and others in others. So the 'entrance' into the long run can differ by firm. So in a situation of losses not ALL of them exit at the same time, but only a group of them do.
- If we sum all the marginal costs and obtain market supply, is the producer surplus equal to the profits of all firms?
No, producer surplus considers only the variable part of profits of all firms. To obtain the profits from producer surplus we must subtract the fixed costs of each firm from producer surplur. Or, in other words profits are lower than producer surplus because they consider fixed costs in their calculation, while producer surplus does not.
- (technical question) Is the slope of the average cost curve the difference of the average cost and the marginal cost at each quantity?
Not exactly, but close. The answer requires calculus and derivatives. Could the person that asked me this question send me an email so I can give you an exact answer? I don't want to post it publicly because its just math derivations.
Thursday, November 8, 2007
Make up sessions: save the dates
Hi all:
thanks a lot for your flexibility for setting the make up sessions.
This is to just remind you of the schedules of the make up sessions. I will confirm the room for one of them as soon as possible
10 am Section:
- Friday 16th: 12pm. Location: TBA
- Monday 19th: 10am. Location: Sever 214 (our traditional room) - remember that we have a lecture on monday at noon.
11am Section:
- Friday 16th: 12pm. Location: TBA
- Monday 19th: 11am. Location Sever 214 (our traditional room) - remember that we have a lecture on monday at noon.
thanks a lot for your flexibility for setting the make up sessions.
This is to just remind you of the schedules of the make up sessions. I will confirm the room for one of them as soon as possible
10 am Section:
- Friday 16th: 12pm. Location: TBA
- Monday 19th: 10am. Location: Sever 214 (our traditional room) - remember that we have a lecture on monday at noon.
11am Section:
- Friday 16th: 12pm. Location: TBA
- Monday 19th: 11am. Location Sever 214 (our traditional room) - remember that we have a lecture on monday at noon.
Tuesday, November 6, 2007
Helpful Hints you should be looking at....
Hi:
These are some helpful hints you should be looking at until now:
An overview of competitive firms complements what we have seen in the last 2-3 sections.
For the next section and a half, there are two helpful hints that you should read: Monopoly and Natural Monopoly
Cheers
These are some helpful hints you should be looking at until now:
An overview of competitive firms complements what we have seen in the last 2-3 sections.
For the next section and a half, there are two helpful hints that you should read: Monopoly and Natural Monopoly
Cheers
Monday, November 5, 2007
Answers to some questions
Hi: although late, here are the answers to some questions you have asked and which I have not been able to give an answer in class.
- Importance of interest payments in the government budget (if you need more info, you can find it at www.cbo.gov): Net interest payments were $226 billion in 2006, or 1.7% of GDP. In absolute terms (in dollars) this number is not the highest (in 1997 the government paid 244 billion). In terms of GDP, it has been decreasing from 3.3% of GDP in 1991, although the lowest figure was 2004 (1.4% of GDP).
- Luxury Tax in the US: I have not been able to find a record of a consistent luxury tax in the US. Looking at the IRS website and other sources the best definition I have found is not satisfactory:
"A tax paid on expensive goods and services considered by the government to be nonessential." IRS
"In the United States, luxury taxes have been levied frequently, especially in wartime, to raise revenue as well as to discourage the flow of essential resources into the production of items not related to the national effort." The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition 2007
"there is no national luxury tax in the US. Some states have different levels of sales taxes for different types of products, so maybe in some states this can amount to something similar to a luxury tax" Friend of mine who is an expert in taxation.
So it seems its not applied generally in the US today at any level.
Hope I was able to answer your doubts with some accuracy.
A
- Importance of interest payments in the government budget (if you need more info, you can find it at www.cbo.gov): Net interest payments were $226 billion in 2006, or 1.7% of GDP. In absolute terms (in dollars) this number is not the highest (in 1997 the government paid 244 billion). In terms of GDP, it has been decreasing from 3.3% of GDP in 1991, although the lowest figure was 2004 (1.4% of GDP).
- Luxury Tax in the US: I have not been able to find a record of a consistent luxury tax in the US. Looking at the IRS website and other sources the best definition I have found is not satisfactory:
"A tax paid on expensive goods and services considered by the government to be nonessential." IRS
"In the United States, luxury taxes have been levied frequently, especially in wartime, to raise revenue as well as to discourage the flow of essential resources into the production of items not related to the national effort." The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition 2007
"there is no national luxury tax in the US. Some states have different levels of sales taxes for different types of products, so maybe in some states this can amount to something similar to a luxury tax" Friend of mine who is an expert in taxation.
So it seems its not applied generally in the US today at any level.
Hope I was able to answer your doubts with some accuracy.
A
Unit Test C: IMPORTANT
Hi guys:
Unit test C is underway! PLEASE NOTICE that the DEADLINE to take it is THURSDAY NOVEMBER 8th. That is, you have 4 days, including today to take it.
It covers the topics on the 'Economics of Public Sector'
Also, I received your graded Units Tests A today . Please remind me on Wednesday to give them to you or come to pick them up at my mailbox in Paul Kelso's office after Wednesday, since I will leave them there after Wednesday's section.
Unit test C is underway! PLEASE NOTICE that the DEADLINE to take it is THURSDAY NOVEMBER 8th. That is, you have 4 days, including today to take it.
It covers the topics on the 'Economics of Public Sector'
Also, I received your graded Units Tests A today . Please remind me on Wednesday to give them to you or come to pick them up at my mailbox in Paul Kelso's office after Wednesday, since I will leave them there after Wednesday's section.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)