Saturday, October 27, 2007

Change in Office Hours and PS3

Hi guys!
Two issues I wanted to inform you about:

1.- Due to last minute (but permanent) schedule issues, I will have to move my Wednesday OH, from 5.00-6.30 pm to 6.30-8.00pm. Same place. I hope this doesn't conflict with the schedules of many of you. My Thursday OH, are still at 4.00-5.30pm.

2.- Problem set 3 is already posted! It is due next friday. You can access it from the EC10 web page. I also put a link in my blog.

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

Unit Test B!

Hi all:

Unit test B is already running! You can take it in Jefferson 250, until Monday Oct 29

Andres

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Grade Ranges for Midterm 1

Hi all: FINALLY. Here they are

A's 80 and above
B's 79.5 - 63.5
C's 63 - 59.5
D's 59 and below

This means A and A- is in the first group, B+, B and B- in the second, etc., etc.

Statistics:
Mean: 75.2
Standard Deviation: 9.1
Maximum: 93.5
Minimum: 51

Friday, October 19, 2007

Externalities : alternative solutions

Public:
- Taxes or subsidies: Allows to internalize the externality.
.- caveats: Goverments need to know the size of the externality and to have an efficient tax system to have an effective tax or subsidy.
- Caps or prohibitions: effectively limit the externality but can be very inefficient.

Private:
- Coase theorem: allocate property rights of the externality to a party and let the parts work out an agreement. In theory: the externality will be internalized if they bargain on a mutually beneficial solution.
.- caveats: this requires identifiable parties which are hurt/benefit from the externality. It also requires to have low transaction costs.
- Create a market for the externality: example: tradable permits. If working, this can allow the parties to internalize the externality probably more efficiently than the government through a tax, because the market generates optimal compensations and it is more flexible than a tax.
- Read the textbook for more details

Externalities: some tips for welfare analysis

- To locate the DWL: locate yourself in the SOCIAL equilibrium. From there, look at the market quantity (a vertical line at that quantity). The DWL triangle should form itself by doing that.
- To do a welfare analysis, you need to focus on the PRIVATE curves, where you will find consumer and producer surplus. You also need to look for the cost of the externality (which should be subtract from the other two). The net SS you will obtain, if you do the analysis correctly should be the SS using the SOCIAL curves, minus the DWL.
- If you put a tax or a subsidy, first you need to locate it using the PRIVATE curves. Then you need to analyze the impact again on the PRIVATE curves and include the cost (benefit) of the externality. And you should be able to prove that with the tax (subsidy) the SS increases and the DWL dissapears.
- Please read the Helpful hint on the Welfare analysis of externalities.
- Post a comment if you have any questions or comments.

Externalities: Key Takeaways

Hi all: here are what I think are the key takeaways of externalities
- A market with externalities will not generate an efficient outcome (SS will not be maximized).
- When production causes and externality MPC <> MSC. When consumption, then MPB<>MSB
- There will be overproduction (negative ext) or underproduction (positive ext). Thus there will be a DWL.
- The way to INTERNALIZE an externality is to make the generators pay the cost(receive the benefit) of the negative (positive) externality. This will automatically cause the consumed and produced quantities to approach the socially efficient quantity.
- The classic public solution is a tax (subsidy) of the size of the externality, which will internalize the cost (benefit) and achieve the socially efficient quantity producted and consumed, eliminating the DWL and maximizing SS.

Thursday, October 18, 2007

A small note on trade

Hi: We analyzed in class the case of imports, when the international price is below the price without trade. This doesn't have to be the case. When countries open up to trade, the international prices of some of their products are higher than domestic prices in some cases and lower in others.
In the first case, the country can potentially EXPORT the good. In the second case the country will IMPORT the good (that is the case we analyzed in class). Please go yourselves over the case of exports and come to office hours if there is something difficult to understand.

Monday, October 15, 2007

New Room for Review Session

Hey everyone:
The room for the RS has changed. Its Harvard 102. Sorry for the late change

Some useful tips for Wednesday's Midterm

- When analyzing welfare effects of taxes and subsidies always look at the fundamental/initial curves. The effective curve is only useful to obtain the new market price and quantity. Once you have it the rest should be analyzed with the original curves.

- When markets are well behaved, the market outcome is EFFICIENT. It maximizes Social/total surplus. CS+PS.

- When government intervenes in such a market it creates a DWL. Why? Because the outcome is no longer efficient. How do we know? Because Q is different from the efficient market Q without the intervention. The DWL must be somewhere between Q and Q*. The cause is quantities, not prices.

- When analyzing welfare effects, look at the changes if you want to do it fast.

- When using equations, when putting taxes or subsidies, isolate P and add or substract the tax or subsidy to the RHS of the equation. This will move the line vertically up or down in exactly that amount.

- When adding demand, beware that demand has breaks and that has different equations between different prices.

If you have any questions about these, please post a comment!

Dead Weigt Loss: an excelent example

The best example of what a deadweight loss is can be found in pages 163 and 164 of the textbook, where Mankiw analyzes the loss of value generated with a tax. I think it is perfect to get the intuition of why it is a loss and why nobody gains from it.

Thursday, October 11, 2007

New Office Hours before the midterm and Review Session time and place

Dear all:

Knowing that it is very unlikely that any of you will show up for the regular office hours next week after the midterm, I will change the 3 hours I should be holding next week on Wednesday and Thursday for a 3 hour OH from 5-8pm on Tuesday, to answer last minute questions you might have for the midterm. Same place as the usual office hours. This means that I will NOT hold OH on Wed Oct 17 and Thu Oct 18.

Also, the Review Session will take place on Monday at Boylston 104 starting at 730pm. I couldn't get a room for 7pm, sorry about that.
I will send you ASAP the RS times for the rest of the TFs for those of you who cant make it at that day and time

Wednesday, October 10, 2007

Midterm 1 memo and instructions

Hi all:

FYI, the EC 10 website posted the instructions and memo for midterm 1. Take a look!

Tuesday, October 9, 2007

Unit Test A already started

Hi all:

This is just a reminder that Unit Test A has already began. You can take it until Thursday October 18, between 630-930 pm, Jefferson 250

Friday, October 5, 2007

Helpful hint for today's class

Hi guys:
Just wanted to tell you that there is a helpful hint on today's (and part of Wednesday's) class: Consumer and Producer Surplus.
It is on the course webpage.

Midterm Material

Hi all:
Here is the material that you must study for the first midterm

Lectures: Mankiw 1 and 2, Stock
Sections and Textbook: Units 1 (CH 3), Unit 2 ( CH 4, 5 and 6), Unit 3 (part, Ch 7 and 8).
Articles: on units 1, 2 and 3 (excluding the ones on trade)
Helpful Hints: Horizontal Addition, Solving for the Equilibrium, Examples of Comparative Statics, Comparative Static of Taxes, Consumer and Producer Surplus, and Welfare Analysis of Taxes and Subsidies

Thursday, October 4, 2007

If you feel you didnt have enough with PS1

Here are a couple of extra questions on comparative statics that I think are challenging (particularly the 2nd one). You might think I am a sadist to put this now, but these exercises are also very useful to test yourselves for the soon-to-come first midterm.

1.- How is it possible that we can observe that for Easter season people consumes more seafood than in the rest of the year, but just at that time of the year is when prices are highest? This shows a case where the law of demand doesn’t hold.

Comment if true, false or if it depends and explain

2.-Given that bread and cheese are usually eaten together they are complements.

a) If we observe that both the price of cheese increased as well as the quantity demanded of bread. What can be the cause of this? A decrease in the price of milk or a decrease in the price of flour?

b) Assume on the contrary, that the price of cheese increased but the quantity of bread produced and consumed decreased. What might be causing this? An increase in the price of milk or an increase in the price of flour?

Explain and graph.

Some clarifications on elasticity

Just to clarify the way we are going to use elasticity:
- In general, no matter if the demand or the supply curve are straight lines, we are going to talk about elastic curves as typically being shallower and more inelastic curves being steeper (with the extremes being a horizontal and vertical curves). Although (as you might read in the textbook in page 97) a linear demand has many different elasticities in every segment of it, when we compare two curves around a common point or region, the steeper curve is always more inelastic than the shallower curve.


For example, in the graph I am showing a decrease in supply under two possible demand settings: a relatively elastic demand and an inelastic demand. Notice that in a region where the old and new equilibriums are, a decrease in supply decreases Q a little and increases P a lot for the inelastic demand, and decreases Q a lot and increases P a little in the elastic case. The steeper demand is more inelastic in the region of analysis as compared to the elastic demand.

If you have any particular questions or doubts about this topic, please comment this post, so I can help clarifying the topic.

Some tips for problem sets

The idea of Problem Sets is that you practice the material through exercises. They also allow you to prepare for midterms and exams. The big difference of PS and midterms and exams is that in PS questions are typically longer and more detailed (some are more difficult) than in exams, and that you have more time in working PSs.
Given those differences, some things I expect you to do in your PS are the following:
- Please don't only put the numeric answer to the questions you are asked. Show your work (in equations) /explain how you got to your answer or why that is your answer (in analytic questions). This doesn't mean writing a page of explanations per question. Be as brief as you can but explain your answers.
- Always label the graphs that you are drawing. Not only the axis and the curves but the relevant equilibrium points and the relevant prices and quantities.
- Please unless necessary, write them yourselves (without a computer I mean). And as I said before, I encourage you to work in groups, but write the PS in your words individually.

Tuesday, October 2, 2007

If you need to hand in problem sets before the corresponding friday session

Hi:
Some of you have asked me where can you hand in problem sets before friday at noon.
Well, I have a mailbox at Paul Kelso's office (pkelso@fas.harvard.edu). It is located in the Littauer Building, first floor, to your left.
So, if you ever need to hand PSs before they are due, please email me (so I know I have to pick them up there) and leave them in Paul's office.

Monday, October 1, 2007

An application of Monday's section

At the beggining of the 1990s Chile's new cinemas incorporated the 'american standard' (great THX sound, comfortable seats, more space between seats, etc). The existing cinemas did not have any of the above (actually they were like old theaters).
The tickets for watching movies in both cinemas had the same price, and people started observing that there were huge lines in the new cinemas and that the old cinemas were pretty empty.
What explains this phenomenon? Is this situation stable? Why or why not?

Additional insights on supply and demand

As you have (hopefully) already learned, individual demand indicates the willingness to buy (quantity) of a consumer at every possible price. But demand also has two additional meanings:
i- The maximum amount I am willling to buy at any given price. (Think about it: at a given price if you were asked to buy more, you would only do it at a lower price)
ii- The maximum price I am willing to pay for any given quantity (this will become clearer when we develop the concept of consumer surplus)

This logic is also valid for market demand.

Likewise, you should already have the notion that a firm supply curve indicates the willingness to sell (quantity of the good) at every possible price. In a similar fashion as demand, the supply curve also indicates the following:
iii- The maximum amount a firm is willing to sell at a given price (the only way I would sell more is at a higher price)
iv- The minimum price a firm is willing to accept to sell a given amount of good. If I were to accept a lower price I would have to sell less.


This logic is also valid for market supply.

Helpful Hints you should be reading/studying now

Hey Guys:

These are the helpful hints you should be reading for last friday's and monday's sections. They will also provide help and ideas for Problem Set 1: comparative statics, solving for the equilibrium, and horizontal addition.
If you have any questions regarding these, post a comment or/and come to office hours.