Wednesday, December 12, 2007
PS6 and lowest PS
PS6 is due on friday. Since we have no section, you can do two things.
a) Hand the problem set to me at Sanders, BEFORE the lecture. I will be outside the lecture until 12:07.
b) take it to the EC10 office (Paul Kelso's office) to my mailbox at 2 pm THE LATEST on Friday. If you want to hand it in before that, that's ok too.
Additionally, as I told you at the beginning of the semester, I will erase your lowest PS. If you don't hand in one PS, I will assume that the non-handed PS is a zero, so I will take the other five for your final grade. If you do all 6 I will take out your lowest percentage score (since not all of them have the same total score) and average the highest five.
Any questions? send me an email
Monday, December 10, 2007
Unit Test E
Hi all,
Just a quick reminder that Unit Test E started yesterday. The deadline for your section is THIS WEDNESDAY. So you have just a couple of days to do it.
Wednesday, December 5, 2007
Grade Ranges for Midterm 2
A's 76.5 and above
B's 76 - 56.5
C's 55.5 - 42.5
D's 39.5 and below
For the group of 6 sections your are part of, these were the stats
Mean: 70.8
Median: 71.5
Max: 97.5
Min: 37
Std Dev: 11.8
Tuesday, December 4, 2007
Helpful Hint
Also, for the previous material (indifference curves and consumer optimization), this is another helpful hint.
Finally, for tomorrow's section, there are two helpful hints that you should read: Labor Supply and Savings.
Cheers
Monday, December 3, 2007
Budget Constraint and Giffen good paper
As I promised, here is the derivation of why the slope of the budget constraint is -Px/Py
We know that when we are ON the budget line we are spending all our income, which is divided among the consumption of x and y. So
I=Px*X + Py*Y
If we isolate Y on the right hand side to obtain the equation of a line of the type y=mx + n, where m is the slope of the line and n is the y intercept, you obtain the following
I-Px*X=Py*Y
Y=-(Px/Py)*X + I/Py.
So the slope of the line is -Px/Py and the y intercept is I/Py or the max amount of Y that I can buy with all my income.
Second, here is a link with the paper I told you about (Giffen goods):
http://ksgnotes1.harvard.edu/research/wpaper.nsf/rwp/RWP07-030
Tuesday, November 20, 2007
Some Key facts about Cutler and Mankiw's lectures
Cutler's lecture:
- The health sector is and will always be important for public policy because:
i.- it is plagued by market failures (unpredictability, VERY imperfect information for consumers, important externalities and lack of competition).
ii.- Its cost as a percentage of GDP is rising extremely fast, becoming a more urgent problem than Social security for the sustainability of Government Budget.
- Medical care provision is very inefficient.
iii.- Instead of having a buyer and a seller you have an intermediary (The insurer) who pays the providers (doctors and hospitals) and charges fees/premiums to consumers.
iv.- The decoupling of the relation of consumers and producers generates a huge problem of moral hazard because consumers get insured, pay a fee and then overuse the health care system since the price they pay is smaller then the real cost of health care. This generates a DWL. But this is in part good because people are insured and that is a good thing.
v.- On the other hand there is also underuse, in situations of chronic disease
- Financing care for the poor is a large issue.
vi.- The question is how to design tax/expenditure to expand coverage
- The politics of health care:
vii.- Republicans: typically care more about the issues of moral hazard and thus look at the overuse of the system (have their minds in its inefficiency and want to shrink it). Democrats: look at the lack of coverage as a problem and thus want to increase its breadth.
Mankiw's Lecture: Global Climate Change and Corrective Taxes
- Basically gives strong support for 'pigouvian' taxes to correct externalities.
- If calculated correctly, corrects the externality and minimizes inefficiencies, and generates correct incentives to decrease emissions of CO2 or use more fuel efficient cars (in the case of taxes to fuel)
- A 'cap and trade' system is worse because it doesn't generate the right incentives (improvements in technology and fuel saving) and can be very inefficient if the cap is set at the wrong (low) level.
- The idea of taxes is politically unpopular.
- Externalities related to fuel tax: pollution externality and congestion externality. Calculations indicate that the taxes to be paid should be much higher than what currently is paid to be optimal.
- Who pays the tax? Depends on relative elastiticies. usually consumer given low elasticity of demand relative to supply, but the fact that the US is BIG, so there is some level of inelasticity of supply, so producers will pay some proportion.
Monday, November 19, 2007
What is included in Midterm 2
Lectures: Cutler, Mankiw
Units: Unit 3 (Ch 9), Unit 4 (Ch 10, 11, 12), Unit 5(Ch 13, 14, 15, 16, 17)
Articles of these units (posted online in the EC10 webpage)
Helpful Hints: Import Quotas, Welfare Analysis of Externalities, an Overview of competitive firms, Monopoly, Natural Monopoly
In summary: International Trade, Externalities, public sector economics, and everything about production, costs, supply and market structure.
Review Sessions, Office Hours before the Midterm and Unit Test D
These are the times and places for the Review Sessions for the second hourly of the TFs I told you about:
- Andres Hernando: Monday 26th 7.35pm-9.35pm, Harvard 102
- Alberto Cavallo: Monday 26th 5.30pm, Sever 304
- Thomas Wei: Monday 26th, 7.30pm-9.30pm, Sever 203
- Silvia Ardagna: Monday 26th, 7.30pm-9.30pm, Science Center C
I already talked to the 4 of them, so you are welcome to attend anyone you want.
Since there are many at the same time, I would suggest you to try to contact classmates in their sections to get an opinion of them. But the 4 of them are experienced and excellent TFs.
Second, Silvia offered me to share her office hours if you wanted to discuss material issues with her. She is holding them this Monday 4-5.30 and Thursday 3-4.30, in her office Littauer 206, that is in the Littauer Building, same as the EC10 office.
Finally: Unit Test D is already under way!! TAKE NOTE that the deadline to take it is NOVEMBER 29th.
Review Session and Monday's class
Since I will be out of the country for almost a week, I will not be able to hold a review session with you. I apologize. Nevertheless, I wanted to leave you in good hands. I have already talked to other TFs and they are happily willing to take you in their review sessions. This TFs are GOOD, and have a lot of experience. Please try to go to one of their RS. They are: Thomas Wei, Andres Hernando, Alberto Cavallo and Silvia Ardagna. I will send you their (and the rest of the TF's) times and rooms for their review sessions.
Also, I will not be here for Monday Nov 26th section. Max Milz (the best TF in my group) will teach you the section.
Andres
Tuesday, November 13, 2007
Make-Up Sections Reminder
This is just to remind you that we will have two make up sections:
10 am Section:
Friday 12pm, Emerson 101
Monday 10am, your regular room
11am section:
Friday 12pm, Emerson 101
Monday 11am, your regular room
Remember that on Monday you also have a lecture in Sanders
Friday, November 9, 2007
A good example of price discrimination
Do you think the costs for LAN change dramatically before and after Dec 16th? Of course not! This is price discrimination. They know that the people that travel close to Christmas value A LOT getting to their homes close to the 24th of December and they charge you for that. People that travel before the 16th on average are traveling for other reasons so they are less willing to accept a price so much higher.
I wouldn't care traveling before the 16th, but I have one final exam on the 19th, so I am screwed.
Is this legal? Yes it is, because they are not discriminating specific people, they are just changing the price depending the time of the year, so everyone that wants to travel on that date (and buys as late as I do) has to pay that price. But they are effectively extracting a LOT of consumer surplus from the people that need and want to travel close to Xmas to Chile.
Answers to questions in section
Here are the answers to other questions asked in class
- If all firms are equal, in a situation of losses where firms in the long run exit, how do we know which ones exit and which ones not? Do all exit at the same time?
This is a very good question and I have found it difficult to provide a convincing answer. But talking to other TFs and doing some research has indicated me that, as I explained in class, one possible explanation to why it is not the case that all firms exit at the same time despite having the same cost structure, is that firms can enter the long run in different periods of time. Some firms renew contracts and fixed costs in some months and others in others. So the 'entrance' into the long run can differ by firm. So in a situation of losses not ALL of them exit at the same time, but only a group of them do.
- If we sum all the marginal costs and obtain market supply, is the producer surplus equal to the profits of all firms?
No, producer surplus considers only the variable part of profits of all firms. To obtain the profits from producer surplus we must subtract the fixed costs of each firm from producer surplur. Or, in other words profits are lower than producer surplus because they consider fixed costs in their calculation, while producer surplus does not.
- (technical question) Is the slope of the average cost curve the difference of the average cost and the marginal cost at each quantity?
Not exactly, but close. The answer requires calculus and derivatives. Could the person that asked me this question send me an email so I can give you an exact answer? I don't want to post it publicly because its just math derivations.
Thursday, November 8, 2007
Make up sessions: save the dates
thanks a lot for your flexibility for setting the make up sessions.
This is to just remind you of the schedules of the make up sessions. I will confirm the room for one of them as soon as possible
10 am Section:
- Friday 16th: 12pm. Location: TBA
- Monday 19th: 10am. Location: Sever 214 (our traditional room) - remember that we have a lecture on monday at noon.
11am Section:
- Friday 16th: 12pm. Location: TBA
- Monday 19th: 11am. Location Sever 214 (our traditional room) - remember that we have a lecture on monday at noon.
Tuesday, November 6, 2007
Helpful Hints you should be looking at....
These are some helpful hints you should be looking at until now:
An overview of competitive firms complements what we have seen in the last 2-3 sections.
For the next section and a half, there are two helpful hints that you should read: Monopoly and Natural Monopoly
Cheers
Monday, November 5, 2007
Answers to some questions
- Importance of interest payments in the government budget (if you need more info, you can find it at www.cbo.gov): Net interest payments were $226 billion in 2006, or 1.7% of GDP. In absolute terms (in dollars) this number is not the highest (in 1997 the government paid 244 billion). In terms of GDP, it has been decreasing from 3.3% of GDP in 1991, although the lowest figure was 2004 (1.4% of GDP).
- Luxury Tax in the US: I have not been able to find a record of a consistent luxury tax in the US. Looking at the IRS website and other sources the best definition I have found is not satisfactory:
"A tax paid on expensive goods and services considered by the government to be nonessential." IRS
"In the United States, luxury taxes have been levied frequently, especially in wartime, to raise revenue as well as to discourage the flow of essential resources into the production of items not related to the national effort." The Columbia Encyclopedia, Sixth Edition 2007
"there is no national luxury tax in the US. Some states have different levels of sales taxes for different types of products, so maybe in some states this can amount to something similar to a luxury tax" Friend of mine who is an expert in taxation.
So it seems its not applied generally in the US today at any level.
Hope I was able to answer your doubts with some accuracy.
A
Unit Test C: IMPORTANT
Unit test C is underway! PLEASE NOTICE that the DEADLINE to take it is THURSDAY NOVEMBER 8th. That is, you have 4 days, including today to take it.
It covers the topics on the 'Economics of Public Sector'
Also, I received your graded Units Tests A today . Please remind me on Wednesday to give them to you or come to pick them up at my mailbox in Paul Kelso's office after Wednesday, since I will leave them there after Wednesday's section.
Saturday, October 27, 2007
Change in Office Hours and PS3
Two issues I wanted to inform you about:
1.- Due to last minute (but permanent) schedule issues, I will have to move my Wednesday OH, from 5.00-6.30 pm to 6.30-8.00pm. Same place. I hope this doesn't conflict with the schedules of many of you. My Thursday OH, are still at 4.00-5.30pm.
2.- Problem set 3 is already posted! It is due next friday. You can access it from the EC10 web page. I also put a link in my blog.
Wednesday, October 24, 2007
Unit Test B!
Unit test B is already running! You can take it in Jefferson 250, until Monday Oct 29
Andres
Tuesday, October 23, 2007
Grade Ranges for Midterm 1
| A's | 80 and above |
| B's | 79.5 - 63.5 |
| C's | 63 - 59.5 |
| D's | 59 and below |
This means A and A- is in the first group, B+, B and B- in the second, etc., etc.
Statistics:
Mean: 75.2
Standard Deviation: 9.1
Maximum: 93.5
Minimum: 51
Friday, October 19, 2007
Externalities : alternative solutions
- Taxes or subsidies: Allows to internalize the externality.
.- caveats: Goverments need to know the size of the externality and to have an efficient tax system to have an effective tax or subsidy.
- Caps or prohibitions: effectively limit the externality but can be very inefficient.
Private:
- Coase theorem: allocate property rights of the externality to a party and let the parts work out an agreement. In theory: the externality will be internalized if they bargain on a mutually beneficial solution.
.- caveats: this requires identifiable parties which are hurt/benefit from the externality. It also requires to have low transaction costs.
- Create a market for the externality: example: tradable permits. If working, this can allow the parties to internalize the externality probably more efficiently than the government through a tax, because the market generates optimal compensations and it is more flexible than a tax.
- Read the textbook for more details
Externalities: some tips for welfare analysis
- To do a welfare analysis, you need to focus on the PRIVATE curves, where you will find consumer and producer surplus. You also need to look for the cost of the externality (which should be subtract from the other two). The net SS you will obtain, if you do the analysis correctly should be the SS using the SOCIAL curves, minus the DWL.
- If you put a tax or a subsidy, first you need to locate it using the PRIVATE curves. Then you need to analyze the impact again on the PRIVATE curves and include the cost (benefit) of the externality. And you should be able to prove that with the tax (subsidy) the SS increases and the DWL dissapears.
- Please read the Helpful hint on the Welfare analysis of externalities.
- Post a comment if you have any questions or comments.
Externalities: Key Takeaways
- A market with externalities will not generate an efficient outcome (SS will not be maximized).
- When production causes and externality MPC <> MSC. When consumption, then MPB<>MSB
- There will be overproduction (negative ext) or underproduction (positive ext). Thus there will be a DWL.
- The way to INTERNALIZE an externality is to make the generators pay the cost(receive the benefit) of the negative (positive) externality. This will automatically cause the consumed and produced quantities to approach the socially efficient quantity.
- The classic public solution is a tax (subsidy) of the size of the externality, which will internalize the cost (benefit) and achieve the socially efficient quantity producted and consumed, eliminating the DWL and maximizing SS.
Thursday, October 18, 2007
A small note on trade
In the first case, the country can potentially EXPORT the good. In the second case the country will IMPORT the good (that is the case we analyzed in class). Please go yourselves over the case of exports and come to office hours if there is something difficult to understand.
Monday, October 15, 2007
New Room for Review Session
The room for the RS has changed. Its Harvard 102. Sorry for the late change
Some useful tips for Wednesday's Midterm
- When markets are well behaved, the market outcome is EFFICIENT. It maximizes Social/total surplus. CS+PS.
- When government intervenes in such a market it creates a DWL. Why? Because the outcome is no longer efficient. How do we know? Because Q is different from the efficient market Q without the intervention. The DWL must be somewhere between Q and Q*. The cause is quantities, not prices.
- When analyzing welfare effects, look at the changes if you want to do it fast.
- When using equations, when putting taxes or subsidies, isolate P and add or substract the tax or subsidy to the RHS of the equation. This will move the line vertically up or down in exactly that amount.
Dead Weigt Loss: an excelent example
Thursday, October 11, 2007
New Office Hours before the midterm and Review Session time and place
Knowing that it is very unlikely that any of you will show up for the regular office hours next week after the midterm, I will change the 3 hours I should be holding next week on Wednesday and Thursday for a 3 hour OH from 5-8pm on Tuesday, to answer last minute questions you might have for the midterm. Same place as the usual office hours. This means that I will NOT hold OH on Wed Oct 17 and Thu Oct 18.
Also, the Review Session will take place on Monday at Boylston 104 starting at 730pm. I couldn't get a room for 7pm, sorry about that.
I will send you ASAP the RS times for the rest of the TFs for those of you who cant make it at that day and time
Wednesday, October 10, 2007
Tuesday, October 9, 2007
Unit Test A already started
This is just a reminder that Unit Test A has already began. You can take it until Thursday October 18, between 630-930 pm, Jefferson 250
Friday, October 5, 2007
Helpful hint for today's class
Just wanted to tell you that there is a helpful hint on today's (and part of Wednesday's) class: Consumer and Producer Surplus.
It is on the course webpage.
Midterm Material
Here is the material that you must study for the first midterm
Lectures: Mankiw 1 and 2, Stock
Sections and Textbook: Units 1 (CH 3), Unit 2 ( CH 4, 5 and 6), Unit 3 (part, Ch 7 and 8).
Articles: on units 1, 2 and 3 (excluding the ones on trade)
Helpful Hints: Horizontal Addition, Solving for the Equilibrium, Examples of Comparative Statics, Comparative Static of Taxes, Consumer and Producer Surplus, and Welfare Analysis of Taxes and Subsidies
Thursday, October 4, 2007
If you feel you didnt have enough with PS1
1.- How is it possible that we can observe that for Easter season people consumes more seafood than in the rest of the year, but just at that time of the year is when prices are highest? This shows a case where the law of demand doesn’t hold.
Comment if true, false or if it depends and explain
a) If we observe that both the price of cheese increased as well as the quantity demanded of bread. What can be the cause of this? A decrease in the price of milk or a decrease in the price of flour?
b) Assume on the contrary, that the price of cheese increased but the quantity of bread produced and consumed decreased. What might be causing this? An increase in the price of milk or an increase in the price of flour?
Explain and graph.
Some clarifications on elasticity
- In general, no matter if the demand or the supply curve are straight lines, we are going to talk about elastic curves as typically being shallower and more inelastic curves being steeper (with the extremes being a horizontal and vertical curves). Although (as you might read in the textbook in page 97) a linear demand has many different elasticities in every segment of it, when we compare two curves around a common point or region, the steeper curve is always more inelastic than the shallower curve.



For example, in the graph I am showing a decrease in supply under two possible demand settings: a relatively elastic demand and an inelastic demand. Notice that in a region where the old and new equilibriums are, a decrease in supply decreases Q a little and increases P a lot for the inelastic demand, and decreases Q a lot and increases P a little in the elastic case. The steeper demand is more inelastic in the region of analysis as compared to the elastic demand.
If you have any particular questions or doubts about this topic, please comment this post, so I can help clarifying the topic.
Some tips for problem sets
Given those differences, some things I expect you to do in your PS are the following:
- Please don't only put the numeric answer to the questions you are asked. Show your work (in equations) /explain how you got to your answer or why that is your answer (in analytic questions). This doesn't mean writing a page of explanations per question. Be as brief as you can but explain your answers.
- Always label the graphs that you are drawing. Not only the axis and the curves but the relevant equilibrium points and the relevant prices and quantities.
- Please unless necessary, write them yourselves (without a computer I mean). And as I said before, I encourage you to work in groups, but write the PS in your words individually.
Tuesday, October 2, 2007
If you need to hand in problem sets before the corresponding friday session
Some of you have asked me where can you hand in problem sets before friday at noon.
Well, I have a mailbox at Paul Kelso's office (pkelso@fas.harvard.edu). It is located in the Littauer Building, first floor, to your left.
So, if you ever need to hand PSs before they are due, please email me (so I know I have to pick them up there) and leave them in Paul's office.
Monday, October 1, 2007
An application of Monday's section
The tickets for watching movies in both cinemas had the same price, and people started observing that there were huge lines in the new cinemas and that the old cinemas were pretty empty.
What explains this phenomenon? Is this situation stable? Why or why not?
Additional insights on supply and demand
i- The maximum amount I am willling to buy at any given price. (Think about it: at a given price if you were asked to buy more, you would only do it at a lower price)
ii- The maximum price I am willing to pay for any given quantity (this will become clearer when we develop the concept of consumer surplus)
This logic is also valid for market demand.
Likewise, you should already have the notion that a firm supply curve indicates the willingness to sell (quantity of the good) at every possible price. In a similar fashion as demand, the supply curve also indicates the following:
iii- The maximum amount a firm is willing to sell at a given price (the only way I would sell more is at a higher price)
iv- The minimum price a firm is willing to accept to sell a given amount of good. If I were to accept a lower price I would have to sell less.
This logic is also valid for market supply.
Helpful Hints you should be reading/studying now
These are the helpful hints you should be reading for last friday's and monday's sections. They will also provide help and ideas for Problem Set 1: comparative statics, solving for the equilibrium, and horizontal addition.
If you have any questions regarding these, post a comment or/and come to office hours.
Saturday, September 29, 2007
Some tips on horizontal addition
- Once you isolate q, you have to effectively add the right hand side of the equations (where P and numbers are). On the left hand side, you don't add, you just say qa + qb + qc = Q. So the sum of 3 individual demands is not 3Q but simply Q.
- The logic of the above is that, by adding the right hand sides of each equation, you are adding the quantities demanded by each person at each possible price.
- If you read the helpful hint on the topic you should already be aware of the possibility that at certain prices some people want to buy zero (the demand of that person is not relevant at that price, so you should not add it at that price). To know what are the key prices at which some demands stop being relevant, I would recommend you to first graph or know at what prices qd turns to zero (intercept with the Y (or P) axis)). That will indicate you which are the prices at which you have to start to be careful in choosing what demands to add and what demands to not add.
- All of the above is also valid for supply curves.
Friday, September 28, 2007
Key Takehomes on Trade and Specialization
- Comparative Advantage: comparison among producers according to their opportunity cost.
- What generates gains from trade? differences in opportunity costs, and terms of trade (trading price) between the two opportunity costs.
- What are the gains from trade: the ability to consume more than what I was able to consume in autarky
- How are they realized? By specializing production in what I have a comparative advantage in (no matter what my absolute advantages are), and selling/exporting my good, and buying/importing the other good.
If you do not understand why this are the answers, email me, send a comment on this post, and come to office hours.